Welcome to Castaways Pizza & Grill
Nestled in Conneaut, OH, Castaways Pizza & Grill offers a delightful culinary escape with a diverse menu that excites the palate. Renowned for their handcrafted pizzas, including the standout Chicken BBQ and classic Pepperoni, the restaurant also serves hearty subs, flavorful salads, and comforting pasta dishes like Chicken Parmesan. Patrons rave about the friendly service and welcoming atmosphere, making it a staple for locals and visitors alike. Highlights include the flavorful Ruben pierogis and generous portions, all at fair prices. Whether you're in for a quick lunch or a cozy dinner, Castaways is a must-visit dining destination.
-
877 Broad St, Conneaut, OH 44030, United States877 Broad St, Conneaut, OH 44030, United States Hotline: +1 440-599-8187
Welcome to Castaways Pizza & Grill, a delightful dining destination nestled in Conneaut, Ohio. Located at 877 Broad St, this charming eatery has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike, thanks to its warm hospitality and diverse menu. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty dinner or a quick lunch, Castaways has something to satisfy every palate.
At Castaways, the menu is a treasure trove of flavors that celebrate comfort food and culinary creativity. Families will find the Little Skippers menu, featuring favorites like 4-inch subs, mac & cheese, and delicious slices of pizza—perfect for young diners. For the grown-ups, the Dinners section is a must-explore, boasting enticing options including the Captain's Feast, butterfly shrimp dinner, and the succulent coconut shrimp. Don't miss out on the satisfying meatloaf or the tender cod, which have won the hearts of many.
Customer reviews highlight the essence of what makes Castaways special. From Tina G.'s experience with their loaded Ruben pierogis to Gabby Liller's praise for the friendly service and delectable Ruben sandwich, it's clear that this establishment is dedicated to quality and customer satisfaction. As Erick Carrera notes, the wings are a standout item, and the welcoming atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for regular visits. Meanwhile, Atty Morgan Caruso and Will Fisher rave about the pizza and subs, with one even featuring commendable sponsorship of local community sports teams.
And let’s not forget the indulgent desserts! Treat yourself to a delightful cannoli or fresh baked pies and cream puffs that provide the perfect sweet ending to your meal. Castaways Pizza & Grill is more than just a place to eat; it’s a cherished community spot that serves delicious food with a side of warmth and friendship.
So, whether you’re a Conneaut local or just passing through, make a stop at Castaways. Call them at +1 440-599-8187 and get ready to enjoy a memorable dining experience. Your taste buds will thank you!
Had the Ruben pierogis, and they were not bad, I think they were deep fried, and I dont like them that way, but that's my me. They loaded them up with the fixings, and that was really good!
We are from Youngstown Ohio stopped in today as we were in town for the first time visiting a family member and the waitress was extremely nice the food was delicious(I got the Ruben ) and price was really fair for quality of food and service I'd go back again
Definitely my new spot, been in this county 3 years and every week I go out and try out what our local restaurants offer, my biggest peep is the wings, if you can't cook them as I order them, then on to the next restaurant. I Definitely give this place 10 stars out of the 5 Google gives you the option to. Very friendly environment among the guests, and Ashley made sure everything was ok....!!!!
I was in Conneaut Municipal Court this morning and I needed to be in Ashtabula County Court this afternoon. Had to stop at Castaways for a delicious lunch! They got me in and out so quickly. Highly recommend. The pizza is awesome and the subs are huge!
First time having Castaways. Ordered 2 pizzas, one Pepperoni and one Chicken BBQ. We got it to go and it took 30minutes and that is what they said it would take. Very friendly and helpful staff. Pizzas were very tasty. The BBQ was better than I expected. Had a light bbq with a white cheese like sause...not sure what it was but it was good. Kids liked the pepperoni. 2 slices were plenty for each of us. We will eat there again...and again. Oh and they are Sponsors for our daughter's basketball team. Thank you!
Very friendly environment at Castaways. Our waitress Lisa was fantastic, she is a very positive individual that makes you feel welcome. The calzone we had was great, with lots of delicious cheese with very bite. We ordered the 12 inch calzone for the two of us, which was large enough we had to take half of it home . Great prices, great food, great place.
Great little place close to the Lake. The server was SUPER friendly, and fast. Just NICE for a 1st visit dining alone! Will definitely be back with my group.
Great food and amazing service! Would highly recommend to everyone!